Wales finally beat the All Blacks, France stopped South Africa's unbeaten run and all four Home Nations finished the weekend with a win. Round 5 gave the Nations Championship its most dramatic November weekend yet, with two narrow victories over the southern heavyweights setting the tone for the last round before Finals Weekend.
England and Ireland added convincing victories over Japan and Fiji, Argentina held off Italy in Genoa and Scotland completed the programme by edging Australia. Five northern wins from six fixtures told one story; the way Wales and France earned theirs made this a weekend that will be remembered well beyond the tables.
Every Round 5 result
13 November: France v South Africa — 21-19
14 November: Italy v Argentina — 14-19
14 November: Wales v New Zealand — 35-28
14 November: England v Japan — 78-15
14 November: Ireland v Fiji — 43-15
15 November: Scotland v Australia — 15-12
Wales 35-28 New Zealand: a wait stretching back to 1953 ends
Wales


New Zealand
T. Williams (1'), D. Lake (5'), A. Griffin (23'), E. James (43'), L. Rees-Zammit (47')
Tries
C. Ratima (9'), W. Sititi (30'), F. Fineanganofo (40+2'), P. Lakai (52')
S. Costelow (2', 6', 24', 44', 48')
Conversions
R. Mo'unga (9', 31', 40+3', 53')
Cardiff delivered the defining result. Wales beat New Zealand for the first time in 73 years, scoring five tries and then defending a seven-point advantage through a demanding finish.
Tomos Williams, Dewi Lake and Archie Griffin helped build an early lead, but the All Blacks recovered to make it 21-21 at half-time. Eddie James and Louis Rees-Zammit struck after the interval, with Sam Costelow converting all five Welsh tries. Peter Lakai's response kept New Zealand close, yet Wales refused to concede the score that would have erased their advantage. For Steve Tandy's side, this was a result with a significance no bonus-point calculation could capture.
Louis Rees-Zammit celebrates Wales' historic victory over New Zealand. Photo: Jan Kruger – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.
France 21-19 South Africa: first-half finishing survives the fightback
France


South Africa
A. Grandidier-Nkanang (14'), T. Attissogbe (23'), L. Bielle-Biarrey (31')
Tries
J. Wessels (29'), C. Reinach (50'), M. Marx (71')
M. Lucu (15', 23', 32')
Conversions
S. Feinberg-Mngomezulu (30', 51')
France did all their scoring before half-time and still had enough to hand South Africa their first defeat of the competition. Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang, Théo Attissogbe and Louis Bielle-Biarrey scored, with Maxime Lucu converting each try for a 21-7 interval lead.
South Africa kept coming despite Jasper Wiese's second-half red card. Cobus Reinach and Malcolm Marx added to Jan-Hendrik Wessels' earlier try, but Manie Libbok missed the conversion that would have brought the teams level. France survived without adding another point after the break, turning a sharp first half into a major result through the narrower margins of the second.
Fabien Galthié celebrates with Maxime Lamothe and Maxime Lucu after France beat South Africa. Photo: Florencia Tan Jun – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.
England 78-15 Japan: Joseph leads a 13-try haul
England


Japan
W. Joseph (0', 9', 19', 24', 55'), F. Steward (14'), E. Genge (17'), C. Murley (28'), B. Earl (39'), G. Martin (44'), B. Curry (63'), M. Smith (67'), G. Fisilau (72')
Tries
W. Dearns (36'), O. Helu (47')
G. Ford (14', 18', 40'), H. Slade (56', 68')
Conversions
N. Saito (37')
G. Ford (7')
Penalties
N. Saito (13')
Will Joseph scored five of England's 13 tries as Japan endured a punishing afternoon at Allianz Stadium. Harry Hockings' early red card made an already difficult assignment harder, and England reached half-time 49-10 ahead.
The scoring continued after the break, with Joseph adding his fifth and Marcus Smith and Greg Fisilau among the later finishers. England secured the attacking bonus point emphatically. The next question is how that attacking confidence translates against New Zealand, whose defeat in Cardiff gives their visit to London an extra edge.
Will Joseph celebrates after scoring five tries for England against Japan. Photo: Matthew Lewis – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.
Ireland 43-15 Fiji: the second half changes the picture
Ireland


Fiji
T. O'Brien (7', 59'), R. Baloucoune (29', 38'), R. Kelleher (45'), A. Porter (53'), N. Timoney (76')
Tries
J. Tuisova (18'), P. Yato (22')
S. Prendergast (8', 53', 60'), C. Frawley (77')
Conversions
B. Volavola (23')
Penalties
B. Volavola (40+2')
Ireland's final margin disguised a much tighter opening half. Fiji stayed close enough to trail just 17-15 at the interval before the hosts took control with 26 unanswered points after the restart.
Tommy O'Brien and Rob Baloucoune finished with two tries apiece. Ireland's ability to turn a narrow lead into a comfortable win was the essential difference between the halves, and it kept the weekend moving in the hosts' favour. South Africa now offer a very different test in Dublin, with both sides heading into Round 6 with plenty at stake.
Robert Baloucoune breaks with the ball against Fiji. Photo: Evan Treacy – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.
Italy 14-19 Argentina: Los Pumas hold their ground
Italy


Argentina
M. Ioane (4'), Penalty Try (64')
Tries
B. Bernasconi (38'), R. Isgro (54'), M. Carreras (59')
T. Allan (5')
Conversions
T. Albornoz (39', 60')
Argentina supplied the southern hemisphere's only win of the round. Monty Ioane's early try gave Italy the lead, but Bautista Bernasconi's response left the teams level at 7-7 at half-time.
Rodrigo Isgró and Mateo Carreras then scored to put Argentina 19-7 ahead. Italy's penalty try brought the gap back to five, but the hosts could not complete the turnaround. Argentina left Genoa with the result; Italy took a losing bonus point and another close defeat into their final league-stage fixture.
Argentina players celebrate their victory over Italy in Genoa. Photo: Simone Arveda – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.
Scotland 15-12 Australia: Russell's penalty makes the difference
Scotland


Australia
M. Fagerson (8'), J. Dempsey (27')
Tries
H. Potter (11'), M. Jorgensen (79')
F. Russell (28')
Conversions
B. Donaldson (79')
F. Russell (74')
Penalties
Scotland's victory was tighter and less fluent than those achieved by England and Ireland. Matt Fagerson and Jack Dempsey scored before half-time, while Harry Potter's reply left Australia 12-5 behind at the break.
Finn Russell's late penalty stretched the advantage to ten points. Max Jorgensen's closing try and Ben Donaldson's conversion reduced the final margin to three, but Scotland held on. The result completed the Home Nations' clean sweep and gave Gregor Townsend's side a win to build on before Japan arrive at Murrayfield.
Jack Dempsey scores Scotland's second try against Australia. Photo: Ian MacNicol – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.
Round 6: the pairings are still to be settled
The final league round takes place on Saturday 21 November: England host New Zealand, Scotland meet Japan, Ireland face South Africa, Italy play Fiji, France take on Argentina and Wales welcome Australia.
Finals Weekend follows in London on 27-29 November, pairing teams according to their finishing position in each hemisphere. Those fixtures should still be described as provisional match-ups until the league programme is complete. This weekend has already shown why assuming the next set of results would be a mistake.
Follow the Nations Championship on AllThingsRugby.com and The Rugby App for results, fixtures and match statistics.
Results and standings
France lead the North on 21 points, with England and Ireland on 20. Scotland and Wales have 15, ahead of Italy on one. New Zealand lead the South on 22, followed by South Africa (21), Argentina (11), Australia (9), Japan (5) and Fiji (0).
Featured photograph: Louis Rees-Zammit celebrates Wales’ win over New Zealand. Photo: Jan Kruger – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images.













