Advertisement
Derby weekend delivered plenty of reminders that form counts for very little when familiar rivals come knocking. Gloucester retained top spot on points difference, Christian Wade joined Chris Ashton in the Premiership record books, Leicester dismantled the defending champions and Harlequins finally got their season moving. Throw in some dreadful weather, a few heated exchanges and some surprising results, and there was plenty to talk about as the Gallagher PREM returned from its European break.
F. Thomas (53'), M. Llewellyn (78')
Tries
K. Tuipulotu (40')
G. Barton (54', 79')
Conversions
G. Barton (31', 36', 38')
Penalties
There are wins built on attacking brilliance, and then there are wins built on simply refusing to let the opposition score. Gloucester's victory over Bath was very much the latter. For large periods of the first half, the Cherry and Whites barely escaped their own territory and kept Bath out while reduced to 13 men. Across the match, Bath had three tries disallowed. Jac Morgan was outstanding at the heart of a defensive effort that had Kingsholm celebrating turnovers like match-winning tries. George Barton provided the scoreboard pressure before Freddie Thomas and Max Llewellyn finished the job. Bath, meanwhile, will be wondering how they managed to dominate so much rugby and produce just five points. Finn Russell and company repeatedly found promising positions but lacked the final touch, while injuries to Santiago Carreras and Guy Pepper made an already disappointing evening worse. Gloucester are showing there is considerably more to this side than their attacking rugby. For Bath, three consecutive defeats across competitions raise some uncomfortable questions.
C. Wade (48'), G. McGuigan (61')
Tries
J. Hodge (49', 62')
Conversions
J. Hodge (59')
Penalties
G. Ford (24')
Christian Wade's remarkable return to the Premiership now has a place alongside one of the competition's most famous records. His 101st league try, finished in the corner against Sale, drew him level with Chris Ashton as the PREM's all-time leading try scorer. Given Wade's years away from English rugby, it is an extraordinary achievement. Yet the bigger story for Newcastle might actually be the result itself. Their first league victory of the season came through a disciplined, physical display in conditions that made attacking rugby particularly difficult. George McGuigan added a second-half maul try as the Red Bulls finally turned pressure into points, while Sale managed little beyond George Ford's first-half penalty. Dan McFarland's side have shown signs of improvement without collecting the results to match. This was the sort of performance they needed to turn that promise into something tangible. For Sale, it was a frustratingly flat showing, particularly given their ambitions this season.
J. Blamire (43'), C. Henderson (51'), F. Carnduff (56'), F. Steward (71')
Tries
J. Pater (6')
B. Searle (71')
Conversions
F. Smith (6')
F. Steward (18'), B. Searle (66')
Penalties
If there is one fixture where you probably shouldn't expect everyone to get along, it's Leicester against Northampton. The East Midlands derby delivered the usual hostility, including a heated exchange involving Henry Pollock, Ollie Chessum and several others as the teams headed towards the dressing rooms. Northampton were actually the better side on the scoreboard at half-time, leading 7-3 after James Pater capitalised on a clever Fin Smith kick. What followed was a very different contest. Leicester's forwards took control, their set-piece became increasingly dominant and the reigning champions simply couldn't live with the pressure. Jamie Blamire, Cameron Henderson, Finn Carnduff and Freddie Steward all crossed after the break as the Tigers turned a four-point deficit into a comprehensive bonus-point victory. For Geoff Parling, this was a significant statement about his side's ability to win ugly before turning the screw. Northampton have the attacking talent to trouble anyone, but this was a reminder that the Premiership's biggest rivalries are not always won by the prettiest rugby.
G. Ibitoye (26'), L. Ivanishvili (78')
Tries
G. Fisilau (52')
J. Williams (27', 79')
Conversions
H. Slade (53')
J. Williams (29', 76')
Penalties
Bristol are usually associated with expansive attacking rugby, but Storm Boelo had other ideas at Ashton Gate. Heavy rain and strong winds turned this West Country contest into a territorial battle where patience, kicking and defensive discipline mattered considerably more than offloads. Harry Randall's distribution created the opening for Gabriel Ibitoye, while James Williams proved valuable with the boot as the Bears built their advantage. Exeter fought back through Greg Fisilau and had opportunities to make the final stages much more uncomfortable, but their decision to chase tries rather than take kickable penalties ultimately failed to pay off. Ibitoye also contributed an important defensive turnover before Luka Ivanishvili's late try removed any lingering doubt. This was Bristol's fifth consecutive league victory over Exeter, a particularly satisfying achievement given how competitive the rivalry has become. Pat Lam's side showed they can adapt when their preferred attacking game isn't available. Sometimes you simply have to accept that the weather has won the argument.
M. Smith (2'), S. Driscoll (14'), Penalty Try (23'), C. Murley (36'), W. Porter (54')
Tries
R. Segun (18'), T. Dan (40+1'), N. Tompkins (61')
M. Smith (3', 15', 55')
Conversions
Marcus Smith could hardly have chosen a better occasion to remind everyone what Harlequins look like when their main playmaker is firing. On his 200th appearance for the club, Smith scored inside the opening three minutes, helped dictate the tempo and produced a brilliant last-ditch intervention to deny Max Malins a seemingly certain try. With Fin Baxter returning to the starting side after a lengthy injury absence and immediately making an impact, Quins looked sharper, more confident and far more cohesive than they had during their winless opening three rounds. Saracens contributed to their own downfall with poor discipline, two yellow cards and a first half in which they struggled to contain the hosts. Seb Driscoll, Cadan Murley and Will Porter were among the try scorers as Quins secured a much-needed bonus-point victory. One win doesn't solve every problem for Jason Gilmore's side, but it does provide a starting point. Saracens, meanwhile, will want to forget an unusually untidy afternoon in southwest London.
Four rounds in, the Premiership is already refusing to follow a straightforward script. Gloucester look increasingly convincing, Leicester have reminded everyone of their physical capabilities, and Bristol are finding different ways to win. Northampton and Bath have plenty of quality but also some obvious defensive and consistency issues to address. The biggest individual headline belongs to Christian Wade, who now needs just one more try to stand alone at the top of the competition's all-time list. With England's autumn internationals approaching, club form and international selection are beginning to collide. And judging by the opening month, there are still plenty more twists coming.
